Factors influencing the use of behavioral management techniques during child management by dentists

Dental anxiety develops from a vicious cycle of bodily arousal from dental stimuli, cognitive interpretation and ineffective coping all working in a runaway feedback loop. Behavioral management strategies (BMT) aim at cognitive reorientation, which results in better compliance with instruction. This paper therefore tried to find out possible factors that influence the effective use of BMT during child dental management during treatment by dental operators in Nigeria.The levels of anxiety pre and post treatment were assessed using the short form of the dental version of the Child Fear Survey Schedule. Also, the type of treatment given to the child, the types and number of behavioral strategies employed during dental management as well as the gender and age of the child were noted. The professional status of the attending dental operator was also noted. Prior to the commencement of the study, the five students in the final year, who were to attend to the children in this study received one week training on the psychological management of dental anxiety in children. Results obtained from the dental operators were compared. The type of treatment received by the child did not significantly affect the dental anxiety score. The number of techniques combined by house officers and senior registrars were significantly higher than would be expected by chance (x2 =16.030, P=0.0001 and x2 =9.000, P=0.0001 respectively). Combination of techniques was also more frequent during invasive procedures and when dental anxiety levels were high. Combining techniques also tended to decrease dental anxiety more significantly than otherwise. Training has a role to play in the basic and efficient use in the management of the child dental patient. The training of dentists should thus entail the full spectrum (content and instructional effectiveness) of all psychological techniques.

1. Baranie JT. Behavior modification techniques. In Ripa, L.W., Barenie, J.T.(eds). Management of dental behavior in children. Littleton, Massachusetts: PSG Publishing, pp 61-73, 1979.

2. Addelston HK. Child patient training. Fort Rev Dent Soc 38: 7-9, 27-29, 1959.

3. Machen JB, Johnson R. Desensitisation, model learning and the dental behavior of children. J Dent Res 53: 83-87, 1974.

4. Melamed BG, Hawes RR, Heiby E, Glick J. Use of filmed modeling to reduce uncooperative behaviour of children during dental treatment. J Dent Res 54: 797-901, 1975.

5. Melamed BG, Weinstein D, Hawes R, Katin-Borland M. Reduction of fear-related dental management problems with use of filmed modeling. JADA 90: 822-826, 1975.

6. Melamed B, Yercheson R, Fleece TL, Hutcherson S, Hawes R. Effects of film modeling on the reduction of anxiety - related behaviors in individuals varying in level of previous experience in the stress. J Consult Clin Psychol 46: 1357-1367, 1978.

7. Klingman A, Melamed BG, Cuthbert MI, Hormecz DA. Effects of participant modeling on information acquisition and skill utilization. J Consult Clin Psychol 52: 414 – 422, 1984.

8. Venham LL, Goldstein M, Gaulin-Kremer E, Peteros K, Cohan J, Fairbanks J. Effectiveness of a distraction technique in managing young dental patients. Pediatr Dent 3: 7-11, 1981.

9. Pinkham JR. The roles of requests and promises in child patient management. J Dent Child 60: 169 – 174, 1993.

10. Klingberg G. Dental fear and behavior management problems in children. Swed Dent J Supplement 103: 1 – 78, 1995.

11. Weinstein P, Nathan JE. The challenge of fearful and phobic children. Dent Clin N Am 662 – 667, 1988.

12. Kuhn BR, Allen KD. Expanding child behavior management technology in pediatric dentistry: a behavioral science perspective. Pediatr Dent 16: 13 – 17, 1994.

13. Pinkham JR. Personality development. Managing behavior of the cooperative pre-school child. Dent Clin N Am 39: 771-787, 1995.

14. Milgrom P,Weinstein P. Dental fears in general practice: new guidelines for assessment and treatment. Int Dent J 43: 288-293, 1993.

15. Melamed BG, Bennett CG, Jerrell G, Ross Sl, Bush JP, Hill C et al. Dentists’ behavioral management as it affects compliance and fear in pediatric patients. JADA 106: 324-330, 1983.

16. McDonald RE. Behavior guidance in the dental office. In: Dentistry for the child and adolescent. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby Company, pp 26-37, 1974.

17. Greenbaum PE, Lumley M.\A,Turner C, Melamed BG. Dentist’s reassuring touch: effects on children’s behavior. Pediatr Dent 15: 20-24, 1993.

18. Sussman NM, Rosenfeld HM. Touch, justification violations. J Soc Psychol 106: 215 –225, 1978.

19. Raadal M, Milgrom P,Weinstein P, Mancl L, Cauce AM.The prevalence of dental anxiety in children from low income families and its relationship to personality traits. J Dent Res 74: 439, 1995.

20. Murray JJ, Niven N. The child as a dental patient. Curr Opi Dent 2: 59 – 65, 1992.

21. Weinstein P, Getz T, Ratener P, Domoto P. The effect of dentists behavior on fear related behaviors in children. JADA 104: 32-38, 1982.

22. Melamed BG, Bennet CG, Jerell G et al. Dentist’s behavior management as it affects compliance and fear in paediatric patients. JADA 106: 324-330, 1983.

23. Thom A, Sartory G, Johren P. Comparison between one session psychological treatment and bengodiazepire in dental phobia. J Consulting Clin Psychol 68:378-387, 2000.

24. Aartman IH, de Jongh A, Makkes PC, Hoogstraten J. Treatment modalities in a dental fear clinic and the relation with general psychopathology and oral health variables. Brit Dent J 186: 467-471, 1999.

25. Folayan MO, Otuyemi OD. Reliability and validity of a short form of the dental subscale of the child fear survey schedule used in a Nigerian children population. Nigerian J Med 11:161-163, 2002.

26. Alwin N, Murray JJ, Niven N. The effect of children’s dental anxiety on the behaviour of a dentist. Internat J Peadiatr Dent 4: 19-24, 1994.

27. Prins PJM, Veerkamp JSF, ter Holst G et al. behaviour of dentist and child patient during treatment. Community Dent Oral Epidemiology 15: 253-257, 1987.

28. ten Berge M, Veerkamp P, Hoogstraten J. Dentist’s behaviour in response to child dental fear. J Dent Child 107: 36-40, 1999.

29. Klingberg G, Berggen U, Carlsson SG, Noren JG. Child dental fear: cause-related factors and clinical effects. Euro J Oral Sciences 103: 405-413, 1995.

30. Barton DH, Hatcher E, Potter R, Handersom HZ. Dental attitudes and memories: a study of the effect of hand over mouth/restraint. Pediatr Dent 15:13-19, 1993.

31. Murray JJ and Niven N. The child as a dental patient. Current Opinion in Dentistry 2: 59-65, 1992.

32. Robert JF. How important are techniques? The empathetic approach to working with children. J Dent Child 62: 38-43, 1995.

33. Tay K-M, Winn M, Milgrom P, Hann J, Smith J, Weinstein P. The effect of instruction on dentists’ motivation to manage fearful patients. J Dent Res 57: 444-448, 1993.